In the literary piece “On
Close Readings,” Peter Rabinowitz argues that close reading is not always the
best form to read. He states that “the way one reads also varies from text to
text.” He later defends his argument by stating that “different authors, different
genres, different periods, different cultures expect readers to approach the
text in different ways.”Later in the piece, Rabinowitz expresses his opinion on
the text students should be exposed too.
I agree with the arguments presented in this piece
because students should not be forced to analyze all pieces of literature in
the same manner. For example, we sometimes come across points, or devices in a
text that are superficial yet we do not
catch because we are occupied in finding the meaning to everything and how it
relates back to the theme, tone or mood. I also believe that students should
read texts that will broaden their horizon.